A New Solution to Illegal Immigrants: Bag ‘em and Tag ‘em

The following is from an article in The Iowa Independent (see link below):

Instead of building a border fence to help stem illegal immigration, the U.S. government should implant microchips into immigrants before deportation, much like what is done with pets, Pat Bertroche, an Urbandale physician and one of seven Republicans running in the 3rd District Congressional primary, said Monday.

While speaking at a Tama County Republican forum, Bertroche made it clear that he wasn’t joking when he suggested treating undocumented immigrants like pets.

From the Cedar Rapids Gazette:

“I think we should catch ’em, we should document ’em, make sure we know where they are and where they are going,” said Pat Bertroche, an Urbandale physician. “I actually support microchipping them. I can microchip my dog so I can find it. Why can’t I microchip an illegal?

“That’s not a popular thing to say, but it’s a lot cheaper than building a fence they can tunnel under,” Bertroche said.

Wow.  Let’s treat illegal immigrants like dogs.  Let’s act as though this is a perfectly sane thing to say when running for political office.  And since Pat Bertroche is a member of a party which is supposed to stand against big government and governmental intrusion into our lives, how does this “bag ‘em and tag ‘em” approach to illegal immigration square with this idea?

Just when I think people cannot be more inhumane or less compassionate of others, along comes this guy who tells the world with a straight face that hundreds of thousands of people should be treated no better than some household pet.  And this guy is a doctor???

It makes me sick.

Install microchips in illegal immigrants, GOP candidate says

By JASON HANCOCK 4/27/10 10:00 AM

Today in History – August 8th

The infant Richard stands outside the Nixons' ...

Image via Wikipedia

1471 – Thomas Kempis, a Dutch mystic and devotional author, died at the age of 91.  His book "The Imitation of Christ,"  a classic in Christian literature, remains in print today.  A few quotes of his follow.

“Always endeavor to be patient of the faults and imperfections of others for you have many faults and imperfections of your own that require forbearance.  If you are not able to make yourself into what you wish, how can you expect to mold another in conformity to your will?”

“Be assured that if you knew all, you would pardon all.”

“All men commend patience, although few are willing to practice it.”

1968 – Richard M. Nixon was nominated for president at the Republican National Convention in Miami Beach and chose Maryland Gov. Spiro T. Agnew to be his running mate.

1974 – President Richard Nixon announced he would resign following damaging revelations in the Watergate scandal.

signature-color picture

“Pastor” Drake Prays for the President’s Death

The “Rev.” (and I use that term sarcastically) Wiley Drake, pastor of First Southern Baptist Church in Buena Park, California, has asked his church’s members to pray for President Obama’s death.  When discussing this with Alan Colmes, here is what he said (click on video below):

A transcript of the above, as well as a few additional comments follows (courtesy of the web site “Crooks and Liars”):

Colmes: …you then said, I asked for whom else are you praying in that fashion and you said President Obama. Are you praying for his death?

Drake: Yes.

Colmes: So you’re praying for the death of the president of the United States?

Drake: Yes. Are you concerned that by saying that you might find yourself on some secret service call or FBI most wanted list. Do you think it’s appropriate to say something like that or even pray for something like that?

Drake: I think it’s appropriate to pray for the will of God. I’m not saying anything, what I’m doing is repeating what God is saying, if that puts me on somebodies list then I’ll just have to be on their list.

Colmes: You would like for the president of the United States to die?

Drake: If he does not turn to God and does not turn his life around I am asking God to enforce in imprecatory prayers throughout the scripture that would cause him death, that’s correct.

Later, Drake would go on to say, “Imprecatory prayer is agreeing with God, and if people don’t like that, they need to talk to God.  . . . God said it, I didn’t. I was just agreeing with God.”

Now the purpose of this post is not political.  I have sworn off most political posting on my blogs.  Rather, I would point out the nonsense that is imprecatory prayer and the idea that this is a prayer form Christians should use.  I would also like to point out that not only is Pastor Drake wrong to  pray in such a way and to instruct his followers to do the same, but that he is just one more example of a Christianity that is hurtful to people and damning to the Church as a whole.  First a couple of definitions:

Imprecation: A curse or denunciation that conveys a wish or threat of evil.

Imprecatory prayer: To pray for evil or misfortune to fall upon another.

Now while the Old Test Testament has several examples of imprecatory prayer (including those listed below).  It is important to note that there is, to my knowledge, not a single example of imprecatory prayer in the New Testament.

Jeremiah 11
Jeremiah 18
Psalms 10
Psalms 55
Psalms 58
Psalms 59
Psalms 109
Psalms 140
Psalms 143

The closest that Jesus come to such a thing is found in Matthew 10:14-15 (and similar verses in Mark 6:11ff, Luke 9:5ff and Luke 10:11).  These verses read:  “And if anyone will not receive you or listen to your words, shake off the dust from your feet when you leave that house or town.  Truly, I say to you, it will be more bearable on the day of judgment for the land of Sodom and Gomorrah than for that town.”  Please note, however, that any judgment to be brought will be done so only by God, and that these instructions are not a prayer for such judgment to be wrought.

There is also a reference in Romans that is important to note as well.  In Romans 12:19-21, Paul writes:

Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God, for it is written, "Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord." To the contrary, "if your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink; for by so doing you will heap burning coals on his head." Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good.

Note that this passage is in direct contrast to advice given by some, including Drake, to use imprecatory prayers.  Once again, any judgment is left up to God, and as is pointed out by many scholars, the reference to “heap up burning coals upon his head” has to do with trying to get the person to repent, not to burning him or her alive.

In fact, a Christian point of view is espoused by Jesus several times in the gospels, including in

  • Matthew 5:44  But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.
  • Luke 6:27  "But I say to you who hear, Love your enemies, do good to those who hate you,
  • Luke 6:35  But love your enemies, and do good, and lend, expecting nothing in return, and your reward will be great, and you will be sons of the Most High, for he is kind to the ungrateful and the evil.

So what are we to make of the references in the Old Testament, particularly the numerous ones found in the Psalms?  I find Walter Brueggemann’s thoughts especially helpful here. Brueggemann, one of the world’s foremost Hebrew Bible scholars, compares imprecatory prayers to venting sessions with a divine psychotherapist.  They are, in other words, honest words that function as a safety valve against harmful action.  And they are not to be taken literally or a model for our own prayers.

People like Drake, who do just that, should be ashamed of the witness they make to the world.  Instead of praying for judgment and death upon those whom they see as enemies of God, they should pray for their salvation.

Signature with Picture

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

One Thing to Know about Today in History – December 21st

Line drawing of Disraeli

Image via Wikipedia

Okay, this will tell you exactly how big of a nerd I was in High School.  In 1978 “Masterpiece Theatre” ran a four-part series on Benjamin Disraeli (played by a very young Ian McShane).  I not only watched all four episodes, but when it was over, I checked out as many books from the library on Disraeli as I could find.  In a matter of days, this man became one of my heroes.

Over the years Disraeli wrote many novels, including “Vivian Grey” (1826), “The Young Duke” (1831), “Contarini Fleming” (1832), “Alroy” (1833), “Henrietta Temple” (1837), “Venetia” (1837), “Coningsby” (1844), “Sybil” (1845), “Tancred” (1847), and near the end of his life “Endymion” (1880).  So what did he do between 1847 and 1880, you ask?  Well, thank you for asking.

You see, the other great love of his life was politics.  Finally elected to the British Parliament as a progressive conservative in 1837 (after six tries), Disraeli served in the House of Commons and the House of Lords (as Lord Beaconsfield) until his retirement in 1880.  During this long period of service, Disraeli also served as Prime Minister twice.  Once for a few months in 1868 and then for six years beginning in 1874. 

Disraeli loved being fashionable and he was a favorite of Queen Victoria.  During his time as Prime Minister, he extended to right to vote to hundreds of thousands of Englishmen.  He was what you might call the first “Compassionate Conservative,” enacting the Artisans Dwellings Act (1875), the Public Health Act (1875), the Pure Food and Drugs Act (1875), and the Education Act (1876).  He also introduced measures to protect workers such as the 1874 “Factory Act,”  and the “Conspiracy and Protection of Property Act” (1875), which allowed peaceful picketing.  The “Employers and Workmen Act” (1878) gave workers to right to sue employers in the civil courts if they broke legally agreed contracts. Disraeli’s great nemesis during much of his time in parliament was William Gladstone, the leader of the Liberal Party, who also served as Prime Minister from 1868-1874, from 1880-1886, and from 1892-1894. 

While I watched the miniseries on PBS, I fell in love with the political process. Disraeli made me want to run for political office (a desire I had until I became a pastor).  He is the reason I minored in Political Science in college, and why I served as an intern at the Kentucky Legislative Research Commission in 1982.  I still owe a large part of my fascination with politics to what I learned about and from this man.

Known as much for his wit as for his political prowess, Disraeli was oft-quoted.

A precedent embalms a principle.

Be amusing: never tell unkind stories; above all, never tell long ones.

Circumstances are beyond human control, but our conduct is in our own power.

Everyone likes flattery; and when you come to Royalty you should lay it on with a trowel.

Frank and explicit – that is the right line to take when you wish to conceal your own mind and confuse the minds of others.

He was distinguished for ignorance; for he had only one idea, and that was wrong.

I must follow the people. Am I not their leader?

Never complain and never explain.

Never take anything for granted.

Seeing much, suffering much, and studying much, are the three pillars of learning.

You will find as you grow older that courage is the rarest of all qualities to be found in public life.

And then there is one of my favorite Disraeli quotes, one which has become a guiding principle for me:

I am prepared for the worst, but hope for the best.

Oh, and before I end this post, I guess I should tell you this:  Disraeli was born on this day in 1804.

A Review on Amazon.com has this to say about the miniseries:

Anglophiles will find much to admire in the 1978 production Disraeli, a comprehensive look at the political and personal lives of one of that nation’s most important historical figures. Benjamin Disraeli (1804-1881), played by Ian McShane (Deadwood, The Golden Compass) in a bravura performance, was "an enigma even to myself," as he puts it. Born to Jewish parents but baptized into the Anglican Church as a boy, he had already established a reputation as an author of "scandalous" novels, not to mention a silver-tongued flatterer and ladies man, when he began pursuing his political ambitions in his early thirties. His career didn’t exactly get off to a flying start; it took him five tries to win a seat in Parliament as a "progressive conservative," and even then his defiant, blustery style earned him little favor among the somnolent stiffs who comprised much of that august body, some of whom dismissed him as "a tinseled coxcomb" whose attire resembled that of "an Italian dancing master" (Disraeli was known to sport lavish amounts of jewelry early in his career). Anti-Semitism didn’t help, either. But he persevered, going on to serve twice as Prime Minister (the first and thus far only Jew to do so) and proving himself to be an eloquent and able leader with a dynamic vision that government should be more than simply a monarch ruling through an enlightened aristocracy (Rosemary Leach charmingly plays Queen Victoria, the monarch in question, with whom Disraeli formed a close and fruitful relationship).

The series also details his personal life, focusing on his 33-year marriage to the considerably older Mary Anne Lewis (Mary Peach), the widow of Disraeli’s former patron and a seemingly frivolous chatterbox whom he admittedly married for her money ("I never intend to marry for love," he said. "It’s a guarantee of unhappiness"), only to end up completely devoted to her. Along the way, Disraeli and his fellow politicians also deal with issues ranging from India and the Suez Canal to Ireland and the looming threat posed by Germany’s "Iron Chancellor," Otto von Bismarck. All of this is accomplished primarily with words (including Disraeli’s own, as well as those of scriptwriter David Butler), and there are lots of them. Disraeli isn’t exactly action-packed–indeed, this is a genteel, stately, and occasionally rather tedious undertaking–but those willing to stick with it for its four-plus hours will find no shortage of rewards. –Sam Graham

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

Prayer And Partisanship

Mary Magdalene, in a dramatic 19th-century pop...

Image via Wikipedia

Patrick Appel on the blog The Dish (see link below) had an interesting post (at least to me) which shows a correlation between how strongly a person identifies with a political party and how much they pray.  What’s interesting about it is that both strong Republicans AND Democrats tend to pray more than others.  I wonder if this is even more so during primary and general elections?

Razib points to this graph showing that more partisan people tend to pray more.

Prayer

Prayer And Partisanship
Andrew Sullivan
Tue, 09 Dec 2008 20:26:00 GMT

President-Elect Barack Obama

Well, I am glad that the election is over, and naturally, given my political inclinations, I am very happy that Barack Obama has won.  As any regular reader of this blog knows by now, I love politics.  I always have.  I vividly remember having intense debates back in 1976 with a couple of my six grade friends over who was better suited to be president:  Jimmy Carter or Gerald Ford (though I do remember one arch-conservative friend supported George Wallace).  And though I am by nature a cynical person, I do believe that it matters a great deal who we elect to govern us, especially when it comes to the President.  The President sets the tone for our nation, and the decisions he (and maybe one day, she) makes have lasting consequences.

But given this, I do want to say that though I fully support Obama, I do not see him as some kind of savior or messiah figure.  He is just as human as the rest of us, and, as he mentioned in his victory speech last night, he will no doubt disappoint me and many others with some of the decisions he makes or policies he seeks to implement.  Nevertheless, I am anxious to see what he might be able to do.

I am also profoundly proud of my nation tonight.  We have elected the first African-American to the presidency.  It is an amazing thing to comprehend.  It was only 54 years ago that legal segregation was ended by the Supreme Court, and much of the Civil Rights movement has taken place in my own lifetime.  As a child in Kentucky in the 60s and 70s, I saw the prejudice and racism that was all too prevalent and visible in the South, and in my 20+ years in the Northeast, I have witnessed the more subtle though just as pervasive forms of the same.  People I knew as a child and youth had no problem using the “N” word to the face of Blacks in my hometown.  In fact, the small section of Bloomfield where most Blacks lived was called “N” Hill by most Whites.  In my own childhood church many folks quit attending when my dad began to bring a Black woman and her family to services.  A kind and generous woman with a beautiful and deep alto that could make the rafters shake had to be told by my father that she could not worship with us anymore.  That he could not bring her to church anymore.  That she was not welcome.

So tonight when I watched the election returns come in, I began to cry.  And when Obama and his wife and daughters walked out on the stage after being introduced as America’s next First Family, I bawled like a baby.

Stuff like this matters.  It matters a lot.  Even if Obama fails in everything he tries to do or accomplish as President, tonight he rose above centuries of racism and oppression.  Think about it:  it was just a short forty years ago that Martin Luther King, Jr. was shot down and killed by hate, but tonight I can say with pride and joy that hope won.  And even if it’s victory is short-lived, tonight hope overcame.  So pardon me, if you don’t mind, while I go shed some more tears and say a prayer of thanksgiving.

Our New First Family

Obama Family